Opal for everyone, tourmaline for the modern list only
Modern list (United States, first adopted 1912 and extended since): Opal, Tourmaline
Traditional list (United Kingdom, National Association of Goldsmiths, first issued 1937 and revised since): Opal
The choice for October is yours: opal is on both lists, tourmaline on one, and our birthstone finder lets you compare any other month.
Opal: silica spheres that split light into colour
Opal is hydrated silica, hardness about 5.5 to 6.5, that shows a play of colour from tiny spheres of silica that diffract light. The colour shifts as the stone or the light moves, which is unlike the steady body colour of most gems.
Australia produces most of the world’s opal, including the fields of Coober Pedy and Lightning Ridge, and Ethiopia is a major modern source.
Looking after opal, which contains water
Opal contains water, so it is sensitive to heat and dryness and can crack if it dries out. Keep it away from radiators and strong sunlight, avoid soaking it, and wipe it gently with a soft cloth. Because it is relatively soft, a pendant or earrings will usually treat it better than a ring worn every day.
The unlucky opal: a superstition with a late origin
The belief that opal is unlucky is often traced to a nineteenth-century novel. It is a superstition that is not well supported by the older history of the stone, which was valued for centuries before that. If you are choosing a stone for October, there is no good reason to avoid opal on those grounds.
Tourmaline: a family of colours in one mineral
Tourmaline is a mineral family found in almost every colour, sometimes several in one crystal, as in the pink and green watermelon tourmaline. Its hardness is 7 to 7.5, so it is generally tougher than opal. Brazil, Africa and Afghanistan are important sources. See the black tourmaline guide for the dark variety.
Why tourmaline joined opal on the American list
October shows a change on the American list, where tourmaline joined opal to give a wider range of colours and prices. The traditional United Kingdom list holds only opal. Because tourmaline comes in so many colours, it is a good choice for anyone who wants a modern October stone that is not opal.
The longer history is in our birthstones overview, and both October lists are summarised in Wikipedia, Birthstone.