One stone in America, two in Britain: May’s lists
Modern list (United States, first adopted 1912 and extended since): Emerald
Traditional list (United Kingdom, National Association of Goldsmiths, first issued 1937 and revised since): Emerald, Chrysoprase
Emerald is the safe May answer on either list, and our birthstone finder will show you the other months.
Emerald: chromium green, internal fractures and oil treatment
Emerald is green beryl, coloured by traces of chromium or vanadium. Its hardness is 7.5 to 8, but it often has internal fractures that make it brittle, so a hard knock can damage it despite the rating.
Most natural emeralds have those internal fractures, sometimes called the garden. Most emeralds are treated with oil or resin to fill them, which is accepted in the trade if disclosed. If you are buying, ask whether a stone has been treated and how. Colombia, Zambia and Brazil are leading sources.
Chrysoprase: the cooler, softer green on the British list
Chrysoprase is apple-green chalcedony, coloured by nickel, with a hardness of 6.5 to 7. It is a microcrystalline quartz, found in Australia among other places, and it is cut into cabochons and beads rather than faceted.
Compared with emerald it is softer and more opaque, with an even, milky green rather than a glassy one. It is often more affordable, which makes it a practical choice if you like the colour but not the price or fragility of emerald.
Why only the British list kept chrysoprase
The 1912 American list and the United Kingdom list both keep emerald, but only the British list keeps chrysoprase. The link between the twelve stones of the breastplate and the months, traced to Josephus, is a tradition, and scholars are not certain which modern stone each Hebrew name in the passage describes. That uncertainty is one reason the lists differ and have been revised over time.
The longer history is in our birthstones overview, and both May lists are summarised in Wikipedia, Birthstone.
Ratna guidance is not a May birthstone
Vedic gemstone (ratna) guidance follows the planets and the birth chart rather than the month, and is covered on our sister site, Nidarshana Vedh; nothing on this page is Vedic advice.
A note on health. Crystals are valued for beauty, meaning and ritual. There is no scientific evidence that they treat health conditions. If you are struggling with your health or mood, please speak to a doctor.