April’s two lists: diamond alone, or diamond with rock crystal
Modern list (United States, first adopted 1912 and extended since): Diamond
Traditional list (United Kingdom, National Association of Goldsmiths, first issued 1937 and revised since): Diamond, Rock crystal
You can set April beside any other month with our birthstone finder.
Both April stones are colourless in their classic form, which is why they are so often confused by eye. What separates them is chemistry, hardness and cost. Diamond is a form of carbon and sits at 10 on the Mohs scale. Rock crystal is a form of quartz, silicon dioxide, at 7. A jeweller can tell them apart in seconds with the right instruments, and a buyer should expect the price to reflect that difference.
Diamond: the hardest natural material, and what that does and does not mean
Diamond forms deep in the Earth as a crystal of carbon. Its name comes from the Greek adamas, “unconquerable”, which reflects how hard it is to scratch. Early diamonds came from India, and today’s well-known sources include southern Africa, Russia, Canada and Australia.
Hardness is not the same as toughness. Diamond resists scratching better than any other natural material, but a hard knock at the right angle can still chip it, because it splits more easily in certain directions. That is why a jeweller will often protect the edges of a ring stone with its setting.
If you are buying, the usual way to compare diamonds is by the “four Cs”: cut, colour, clarity and carat weight. It is worth asking for a grading report from a recognised laboratory for anything of significant value.
Conflict stones, lab-grown diamonds and asking about origin
The diamond trade has a history of conflict stones, meaning diamonds sold to fund armed violence. The Kimberley Process certification scheme was set up in response, and buyers who care about origin can ask a seller what documentation comes with a stone. Laboratory-grown diamonds are chemically identical to mined ones, so the question to ask is simply which one you are being sold, and the answer should be written on the paperwork.
Rock crystal: April’s quieter stone
Rock crystal is clear, colourless quartz. People have carved it into beads, bowls and seals since antiquity, and the word crystal itself comes from the Greek for “ice”. Some ancient writers believed it was water frozen so hard it could never melt, an idea that tells us more about how people thought than about the mineral.
At hardness 7 it is durable enough for pendants, beads and earrings, but a ring worn daily will pick up scratches over the years. It is plentiful and affordable, which makes it an easy choice if a diamond is out of reach or you simply prefer a stone with an older, plainer reputation. Our clear quartz guide covers the same material in more detail.
Because clear glass is also sold as “crystal”, it is sensible to buy rock crystal from a seller who states plainly that it is natural quartz.
Why a 1937 British list gave April a second stone
April is a small case study in how the lists were built. The United Kingdom list, first issued by the National Association of Goldsmiths in 1937, keeps an older companion stone for several months, and for April that companion is rock crystal. The American list keeps just one headline gem. Both lists were shaped by the jewellery trade as well as by tradition, so April shows that a birthstone is partly a custom and partly a sales convention.
The history of both lists is in our birthstones overview and summarised in Wikipedia, Birthstone.